Craps Paytable Comparison: Field Payouts & Buy Fees

Sam Originally published Updated

Compare two rule sets for the same wager. Start with an example, then enter the payouts or fee handling you have actually confirmed. A lower expected cost does not guarantee a win or make a larger wager affordable.

Rule A and Rule B are your inputs, not casino recommendations. This tool does not verify a casino’s current paytable, permitted stakes or legality.

Choose a comparison

$1–$100,000. Whole dollars only; no silent rounding or cap.
Rule A
Rule B

Why the Field layout matters

Ordinary Field winners pay even money. Extra payouts on 2 and 12 can reduce expected cost, but only those rare totals receive the extra amount. For a $20 wager, double on both gives an expected loss of about $1.11 per roll; double on 2 and triple on 12 lowers it to about $0.56. The chance of a losing roll remains 20 in 36 in both examples. The result is an average over repeated wagers, not a prediction of the next roll.

Why fee timing matters

A $25 Buy 4 wins $50 gross at true odds. An exact 5% fee is $1.25. Charged upfront for a decision, it produces a $48.75 net win or a $26.25 total loss. Charged only on a win, the net win is still $48.75 but the loss is $25. Because 4 wins one third of resolved 4-versus-7 decisions, expected cost falls from $1.25 to about $0.42 per decision. Here the edge is 5% versus 1.6667% of the $25 base wager; an upfront-fee-inclusive denominator would give a different percentage.

Rounding can change the comparison

A $24 Buy 5 has $36 true-odds gross profit. With a $1 fee only on a win, expected loss is $0.40 per resolved decision, or 1.6667% of the base wager. Exact 5% is $1.20, making expected loss $0.48, or 2%. Ask for the actual fee and accepted wager amount; minimum fees and payout breakage do not scale proportionally. The tool’s rounding choices are models, not assertions that a jurisdiction allows those rules.

Put both expected costs on the same clock

The Field result is measured per roll. The Buy result is measured per resolved decision, which may take several rolls. A $25 win-only Buy 4 has an expected commission of $1.25 × 3/9, about $0.42 per decision. If it is working and renewed at the same size continuously, only 9 of 36 rolls resolve it: three combinations of 4 and six of 7. Its expected cost per physical roll under that assumption is about $0.42 × 9/36, or $0.10 using the unrounded numbers.

The double-2, triple-12 Field at $20 averages about $0.56 per roll because every roll resolves it. The amounts at risk on a losing roll are still $25 for this Buy and $20 for the Field. If you turn the Buy off, take it down between decisions or vary the stake, use the actual active rolls and amounts when tallying exposure.

Before relying on a paytable

  • Read whether payouts are “to” or “for”; this tool uses profit ratios stated “to.”
  • Confirm the exact number, wager amount, fee basis, collection timing and rounding with the crew.
  • Check whether the wager is working. These Buy examples assume a working bet held until the number or 7 resolves it.
  • Ask what happens to commission if a bet is removed, increased or renewed; those actions are outside this model.
  • Keep profit separate from returned stake. A standing winning Buy bet may remain exposed.

Use the Payout Auditor for a settlement check, the settlement walkthrough to follow rack and layout money, and the tools hub for other tasks.

Reference and scope

The Massachusetts Gaming Commission Craps and Mini-Craps rules describe Field outcomes and Buy-bet true odds, including upfront and win-only fee treatment. Reference checked October 3, 2026. The calculator explores selected paytable assumptions; it does not certify current casino availability or local approval of a rounding convention. It models fair independent dice, no side bets, and no additional incentives.